As a seasoned player I have found this to be very awkward. Starting in March every time I face an identical overall no matter when I time it I still lose the ball. I still win quite a lot of games, but it is still pretty annoying at times.
What kind of Cs do you use? I normally use C's that can shoot very well be and I haven't won many tip offs in the same period but there are Cs that I've had that can't shoot and are very tall that I never got a top off win with like flashback Muresan